Isabella Mazzone discusses the proposed R. 3337 draft labelling regulations in South Africa, focusing on front-of-pack warning labels (FOPL).
Transcript
[00:08][Eon] Welcome to Legal Talk here on eRadio, and in our poll a week ago, we asked you: do you think more warning labels on food products will change consumer habits here in South Africa? The majority said no. Old habits die hard. Then 33% said it's worth a try, and the remainder, 17%, said yes, it could. But the majority, 50%, said no. Old habits die hard. They don't think more warning labels on food products will change consumer habits here in South Africa. Joining us today is associate attorney at Hahn & Hahn's Department of Food and Consumer Law, Isabella Mazzone. Isabella, welcome back. Nice to chat to you again.
[00:53][Isabella] Thanks so much, Eon. Actually, didn't know the results until you said it now. Jeez, did we really get that kind of a result? Oh, wow!
[01:01][Eon] Indeed. So, the majority said no. Old habits die hard. I actually agree.
[01:06][Isabella] I mean, I don't think they're wrong, but be that as it may, we'll have to talk about this.
[01:13][Eon] So, today you're actually talking about it. The R. 3337 draft labelling regulations were published way back on the 21st of April 2023 already, and we have yet to see them being promulgated or another draft in circulation. Now, since we last spoke about these labels in 2023, has there been any kind of update, Isabella?
[01:37][Isabella] Yeah. So, I mean, they were, like you said, published in April 2023. And then, in terms of the law, the public was given a consultation process, so to submit their comments. Originally, it was only for three months, so until the 21st of July, and then it was extended by another two months, so the comments actually closed on the 21st of September 2023. And, you know, the Department of Health actually, you know, came out to say, look, they had so many properly substantive submissions from over 179 companies and organisations, and it was hundreds and hundreds of pages, and then, once they actually captured it and put it all into one document, that document was 6,000 pages. That's how many comments were submitted, because it's obviously super controversial and heavily contested regulations, and if they do come into effect, it's going to change a lot of things for South Africans. So, you know, the Department of Health has said that they had to actually put together a technical team, which only consisted of four people. I mean, it's not many people who have to go through all of these comments and then actually identify the issues and consider amendments. And they have actually come out to say that their review of all the comments is, in fact, complete. And apparently, they have, in fact, reworked the proposed warning labels, which we'll talk about a bit later. Now, essentially, what's left is that they have to discuss the draft with their legal services. Hopefully, they'll hold a feedback session with industry and the various consumer advocacy groups, and then, obviously, finalise into a final draft and submit to the Minister of Health for publication. However, there's also been a process happening in the background simultaneously, which has been the referral of this regulation, this draft regulation, to NEDLAC. So, NEDLAC is the National Economic Development and Labor Council. And, you know, the referral itself was disputed because it's not a norm for this kind of a regulation. However, it was done, and they have tabled those regulations before NEDLAC. And, yeah, I think this was done in August of this year, in fact, with the main industry driver being the CGCSA. However, they don't actually participate by themselves. They are part of BUSA, which is the Business Unity South Africa entity. And, yeah, so they actually tabled it formally on the 26th of August. The task team met where they can engage on the various issues, but no one outside of the government has actually seen any kind of a revised draft of the regulation. And, as well as the NEDLAC submissions, I mean, those we will only see once they've actually finished tabling it and then submit and record their own report. So, now more than three years after the publication of the draft, process is still not quite complete. There's no firm publication dates. However, we do have some indications, we've heard the rumors, we've heard the whispers, that these regulations could still be published by the end of 2026. And this is a very, very high possibility considering the history and also considering how they've published regulations before. They have done that where they post regulations to the, you know, the e-government printers on the 24th of December, you know, these kinds of things do happen. So, you just never know. We are currently just monitoring that Government Gazette website every day to make sure we don't miss it.
[05:25][Eon] Yeah, okay, and do you think the front-of-pack warning labels will be removed from the regulations? Or do you think that the Department of Health is going to go ahead with implementing them once the regulation actually comes out?
[05:39][Isabella] So, look, obviously there's been a huge pushback from industry due to the way in which they are trying to implement these warning labels, such as, you know, the proposed size on the label. It's going to be quite a large size, going to be 25% of the label, as well as the various nutrients that will need these warnings. So, it's just very controversial, and of course, some industries will be more affected than others. Just because of the nature of the products that they produce. There are also really huge concerns from even the healthier food product companies, as the current draft is trying to implement a warning for artificial sweeteners, when in fact, the reason sweeteners are being used so widely and by so many people is to provide alternatives for those with diabetes or celiac, as well as to deal with the issue of our health promotion levy, which I think most people call the sugar tax, so to reduce the amount of sugar consumed by South Africans. So, this entire implementation, in some ways, seems counterintuitive and poorly thought out. The only other country in the world that has warnings for sweeteners is Mexico. So, obviously, there's great concern. Not really on if it gets implemented, but how it gets implemented. And that implementation must be science-based, as opposed to causing, you know, undue concern and fear amongst consumers over products that are not actually that bad. I do think, you know, the FOPL, which is the Front of Pack Warning Labels, that's just what we all call it, otherwise it's quite a mouthful. So, we do think FOPL will most probably be implemented, as it has in quite a number of countries all over the world, but we are hoping that the current version that was proposed in R. 3337 is not the final one. And that it will be amended to be a lot more, you know, consumer, South African consumer market-driven and a more science-based approach with less complicated restrictions.
[07:44][Eon] Okay, and just lastly, Isabella, what could these warnings look like and which products will be targeted?
[07:52][Isabella] So, if we look at the proposed design in the draft R. 3337, it's actually very, very similar to the design of those in South America. So, I was just in South America, and I was fascinated to see the labels there because they do have a lot of these warnings with just different, sometimes different wording, sometimes different shapes. But it is there, but ours specifically follows the Chilean design. Chile was actually the first country in the world to implement this mandatory FOPL. They actually passed the law in 2012, and then there was a whole four years until they actually started implementing it in 2016. They've had quite a long phase-in period, which is a lot more realistic, I think, because having to change every single label in a country takes some time. Anyway, so the design that they have, in fact, proposed is a black-and-white warning triangle, and then it contains in their text that says, "high in", alongside the specific nutrients that would be applicable. So, the targeted nutrients in this case would be added sugar, added salt, added saturated fat, as well as artificial sweeteners. Now, what's really interesting is that for the sugar, salt, and saturated fat, it's about whether it has been added. Whereas for the artificial sweeteners, of course, it's just if it contains the sweetener or not. So, this will apply to all pre-packaged products, and there are various limits for the added products, and if you exceed a total nutrient value of the specific cut-offs for solids per hundred gram or for liquids per hundred mil, then you will need to place this warning on. So, for example, for sugar, if you contain more than 10 grams per hundred gram or 5 grams per hundred mil of sugar, added sugar rather, then you will need a warning. For saturated fat, it's 4 grams per hundred gram solid and 3 grams per hundred mil. Added saturated fat for sodium, it's 400 milligrams for solids and 100 milligrams for liquids. And then, like I said, for sweeteners, any amount of sweeteners has to be declared, which is insane. So, just in terms of how they'll actually be displaying the products and the rules, FOPL will have to be clearly visible and integrated completely into the packaging and the marketing, not just the packaging, any advertising as well, may not be covered by any other element on the label, and it will have to cover a minimum of 25% of the front of the label, so the consumer-facing label. It's also quite a hectic nutrient assessment that they have to do. So, they obviously first check the ingredient list for the added sugars, fats, or sodium, as well as the content of artificial sweeteners. Then they do a naturally occurring nutrients test as well, and just a total nutrient evaluation. And then, once they've actually gathered all of that information, they can then check that against the cut-off values. So, it's quite intense. It's also, if there are multiple warnings, you will then have to have an anchor that says warning with an exclamation mark. And then there are also various restrictions on marketing and claims. So, if your product contains one of these warning triangles, you will also not be able to make any health or nutrition claims, such as high in fibre or low fat or anything like that. And you will have a very strict ban on any marketing to children. So, these warnings are not as simple as just a warning. It has really, like, a domino effect on the way that you will be able to market your product.
[12:03][Eon] Wow, this is interesting. And also interesting to see that they're going for a black and white triangle instead of - I was picturing something red or perhaps yellow, you know, but maybe it is actually done on purpose to stand out because most labels are colored. So, maybe the black and white will stand out more. I don't know, maybe. I don't know.
[12:24][Isabella] Yeah, look, like I said with the comments, there were a lot of, you know, people saying, well, why did we choose this option? They've got the robot markings in Europe. You know, there's a lot of different designs that could be utilised, and they're basically querying, you know, how did the Department of Health get to this result? Did they do market research? So, you know, it's hard to say why they chose it. We do know it's exactly the same as the Chilean one, so we know where they got the design from, but why they chose it specifically for South Africa is, like I said, super contested.
[13:03][Eon] Very interesting. There's still time left before the end of the year. So, who knows what's going to happen. We'll definitely keep an eye on it, Isabella. Thank you so much for telling us all about it today.
[13:14][Isabella] No, no problem. Thank you so much. We'll keep our eyes peeled.
[13:18][Eon] And then we'll chat again soon. That's Isabella Mazzone from Hahn & Hahn Attorneys' Department of Food and Consumer Law on Legal Talk today. Thanks, Isabella.
[13:30][Isabella] Thank you.
