Jaco Hamman discusses common legal mistakes clients make in litigation & arbitration, often leading to unfavorable outcomes despite believing they are in the right.
Transcript
[00:09][Eon] Legal talk on eRadio with Hahn & Hahn Attorneys, and I'm joined today by Jaco Hamman from the firm. It's nice to chat to you again, Jaco. Welcome.
[00:19][Jaco] Hi, Eon. Thanks. Nice to be back.
[00:22][Eon] Now, Jaco, you wanted to talk about something that you see regularly with your clients. Do you mind sharing it with us?
[00:31][Jaco] Yeah, sure, Eon. As you know, we posted a question on LinkedIn where we made the statement to say: you receive a summons or a notice of arbitration, but you know that you are right. And then the question is: what will matter most when it comes to winning? And the options were: my word and my honesty, documents delivered on time was the next one, third one, hiring the best lawyer, and then the last one, not sure. Now, lo and behold, as I had predicted, although I hoped that I was wrong, is that the majority of the participants said my word and my honesty, so 36%. And then the next ones were documents delivered on time, 27%, and hiring the best lawyer, 20%, and then 9% was saying that not sure. So, the not sure ones is also very good, because it's better to not be sure than keep your ears open. As opposed to anything else. Many clients assume, as you see here, that because they know they're in the right, the outcome will just take care of itself. But the reality is that once you are in litigation, in a court proceedings or arbitrations, especially if you're defending it, there's two things that decide the results. The first is strict timelines and proof, and clients often underestimate both of those.
[02:02][Eon] And these timelines, Jaco, how strict are they?
[02:05][Jaco] Very, very strict. So, you have to abide by that timeline. So, let me give you an example. So, let's say you've now received a summons and a particulars of claim. Then your first timeline is a notice of intention to defend that you have to serve. So, you go to attorney, you say there, now, depending on the type of entity in court, there's a difference in those specific timelines, but that's the first one. Then thereafter, you now need to file your plea. But let's say for argument's sake, you then don't keep to that timeline. Then the process says they can stop you and that you then don't file that, that you're then not allowed to put your version of events on the table. But what happens more often than not is not the failing to deliver the document. It's the failure to do it properly, in the sense that you know what has happened or your version of what has happened. Your attorney doesn't know. He knows the portion that you tell him, but now he needs to get evidence, the proof that supports that. Now, what happens is the attorney keeps on asking the client, remember to send me this document, remember to send me all your documents, and then that doesn't happen. Then three, four days before the deadline, the attorney now frantically starts drafting a version that he now needs to put in front of the judge or the arbitrator. Then he delivers that, but then the documents are not there yet. Or, remember, and here's what happens, clients interpret a document the way, and I say this with utmost respect because my experience, I've seen this numerous times. Clients interpret a document the way that they believe it should be interpreted, not objectively. I've seen cases where I've spoken to a client and then they say, no, they've got this contract with somebody that says one, two, and three. Then when I look at the document that they send me, then it's not even a contract. One that I'm thinking about now, it was more of a query that somebody had asked based on. So, now you have to remember, now I've drafted the whole defense based on this contract that isn't even a contract per se. And that's the problem with the timelines. So, you have to be as quick as possible to get your attorney, get him all the documents, and not just the documents that you think are important. You have to send everything to him. Also, the documents that will count against you, and that has to happen in that timeline.
[04:56][Eon] Okay. And then the second point you mentioned, Jaco, was proof. Surely, if I know what happened, I mean, that counts for something?
[05:04][Jaco] It does, but only to a very limited extent. So, let me give you an example. So, the client will tell me a version and say to me, this one, two, three, and four has happened. Now, I say, that's fine, it's good, but you need to send me the documents that can prove this. Then the client sends me two documents. And I say, is that all? And remember now, keeping the timeline in the back of your mind, and clients have their own business that they need to operate from, so then they say, okay, yeah, that's all. But then when we come to the hearing, then suddenly the client, when he's under cross-examination, he says, oh, no, there's more documents. But those documents aren't put in front of the judge or the arbitrator. Then what? Even if you then try and put the documents then in front of the judge and the arbitrator, and there's processes to do that, that judge or arbitrator is going to ask serious questions to why it wasn't provided previously. And remember now, a judge or an arbitrator will say to himself, but surely if somebody sues me, for argument's sake, for ten million, I will give all the documents to my attorney. So, then suddenly it doesn't help that you have put a version in front, but you haven't gotten all the documents to back it. So, you know, the reality is my mom used to have a, well, still does, she has a saying that says there's three versions of the truth. Mine, yours, and what actually happened. Now, I've added a fourth, and the fourth is the version that you are able to prove. So, you need to put forward a version with documents that an objective person that wasn't there can say, you know what, this is what most likely happened. Now, if you don't put a document in front that corroborates your version, but the other side puts a document in front of the judge that corroborates their version, then you start having trouble.
[07:09][Eon] Yeah, and is there no way that your lawyers can fix that problem?
[07:14][Jaco] So, we can, but only up to a certain extent.
[07:17][Eon] Okay.
[07:18][Jaco] And here comes the biggest challenge of all of it. You can do, or as an attorney, you can do all the type of footwork that you want. The reality is that you've got a version, and that version has got certain evidence. And if that isn't put in front of the judge, then it becomes a problem. Or even worse, they don't give me a document. Now, under number 99, this document comes to the forefront. But now the opposition has used that document to interpret to a certain extent, and now we don't have the time, because of these strict timelines, to try and find a counter document to this. So, that's why it is so, so important.
[08:06][Eon] Okay, so, Jaco, if someone received a summons or an arbitration notice tomorrow, what should they do?
[08:14][Jaco] So, three things. Firstly, don't ignore it. I see a lot of times people just think, ag, no, this is nonsense, and they leave it. You can't do that. And then, note the date that you received it, because the deadlines start running from what we call service. That's just the date that you receive it. And then, secondly, contact an attorney immediately. Don't wait a couple of weeks and say, "Oh, okay, now I'll do it then or then." Do it immediately. So, thirdly, and that's where the third point comes in, and that is start gathering everything. Contacts, emails, messages, invoices, proof of payments, WhatsApps. Go and download your WhatsApp conversations, and give everything to the attorney. Let the attorney then decide which of that information and documents is important. And remember again, like I said, that the attorney will, especially on the first look, he will objectively look at those documents and decide then what is in your favor and what helps and what doesn't.
[09:20][Eon] Yeah, and that's where Hahn & Hahn, of course, comes in.
[09:24][Jaco] Exactly, yeah. So, when we act in litigation and arbitrations, it's for claimants and the defendants, and the earlier we are brought in, the more options we have. So, if you are facing a claim or think one is coming, rather get in touch with us now already, and let's start assessing and let's start preparing.
[09:45][Eon] Yes, and do not ignore it, as Jaco just said. Thank you, Jaco. That was very interesting once again. Nice to chat to you.
[09:54][Jaco] Excellent. No, thanks, Eon, much appreciated. Thanks for your time.
[09:58][Eon] And thank you for yours. That's Jaco Hamman from Hahn & Hahn Attorneys for this week's Legal Talk.
